Patent Valuation, Monetization and Investments

Blog

Markman Advisors Patent Blog

by Zachary Silbersher

Posts tagged Judge Mayer
Let’s face it—the Supreme Court will never save us from Alice.

The Supreme Court has denied the recent bid to fix Alice and Section 101 jurisprudence.  In two cases that each petitioned for certiorari, Tropp v. Travel Sentry, Inc. and Interactive Wearables, LLC v. Polar Electric Oy, the Federal Circuit affirmed district court decisions holding the asserted patents directed to ineligible subject matter.  The Supreme Court’s denial is particularly acute since the Solicitor General recommended that cert be granted.  And it is more painful given that this denial follows another recent instance where the Solicitor General also recommended that the Supreme Court take up Alice.  Once again, the patent community mourns another lost chance to clear up the mess that has become Alice.  But let’s face it—will the Supreme Court ever save us from Alice? . . . The answer is, probably not.

Read More
Google’s policy statement on patent reform reiterates its desire that patents should be worthless.

On April 28, Google published a policy statement on the need for specific patent reforms. The statement was published by Google’s General Counsel, Halimah DeLaine Prado, and titled, Reforming the patent system to support American innovation. The statement is a notable read given that it issued from one of the largest Big Tech companies. The statement identifies four concrete areas where patent reform is purportedly required. Behind its prescriptions lingers its agenda—namely, that patents should have no value at all.

Read More
Does Alice require fact questions or not? The Federal Circuit appears split.

Earlier this year, the Federal Circuit issued two precedential decisions that were predicted to stem the tide of early dismissals based upon Alice motions.  The cases were  Berkheimer v. HP and Aatrix Software v. Green Shades Software, and there were both deemed precedential by the Federal Circuit.  A recent concurrence at the Federal Circuit, however, shows that the Court may be splitting over the rationale underpinning Berkheimer and Aatrix, and that split may be heading for the Supreme Court. 

Read More